I killed my sourdough starter

I killed my sourdough starter. It’s my fault - totally. We took a couple of back-to-back trips and I didn’t feed my starter in between. When I pulled it out after a month, there was mold. So I had to toss it.

I had some sourdough discard in a separate container in my refrigerator. I tried to revive it with twice daily feedings for 10 days. I had some bubbles, but it just never got strong again.

Why Wasn't My Sourdough Discard Coming Back to Life?

I tried to revive the sourdough discard for 10 days. It just never got strong. So I did some research to understand why.

Me attempting to revive Collette and saving the sourdough discard for other use. Sadly, I need to toss the discard - not sure its safe to use.

I assumed that something in my starter was preventing growth. I did some research to understand and came up with a couple of reasons. When sourdough discard sits in the refrigerator for a long time without feeding, acidity increases making the environment too acidic for healthy yeast growth. Another thing that can be happening is that bacteria can outnumber the active yeast and basically stopping the process of growing new yeast.

So, while my discard wasn’t moldy, that didn’t mean it was healthy enough to bounce back.

I had been feeding my starter at a 1:1:1 ratio (equal parts starter, flour, and water). But if my starter was too acidic, it was carrying that acidity into every feeding. A higher feeding ratio like 1:5:5 would help by diluting the accumulated acids and providing more fresh flour for the yeast to feed on.

What to do…

I am going to give it one more try. My research is inspiring me. 🙂For 3 days only.

Here we go! Day 1!

Day 1: Feed with a 1:5:5 ratio 

10g of starter

25g rye or whole wheat flour

25g bread flour

50g water

Day 2: Looking for signs of life.

I’m checking for bubbles, expansion, or a change in the smell. If there is no activity after 24 hours, I’m leaving it for another 12 hours to give the yeast time to get going.

If there is activity and signs of fermentation, I’ll switch to a 1:2:2 feeding ratio (20g starter, 40g flour, and 40g water).

Then, I wait and watch. I’ll check it at dinner time (12 hours) and if there is no activity, it will rest overnight and I’ll check again at 24 hours.

Day 3: This is do or die day!

If there is activity, I’ll continue feeding at 1:2:2 ratio until it doubles after 3 consecutive feedings. Then, switch back to the regular feeding schedule of every 24 hours.

If there is no activity, I’m tossing the old starter and starting fresh.

Next!

I’ll report back tomorrow morning. Let’s see how this experiment plays out!

Next
Next

A Lazy Friday Morning (At Least I Think It’s Friday)