Knitting Fair Isle Mittens

I need to remind myself that I only started knitting again in January of this year. Years ago I knit complicated patterns, including Fair Isle mittens. But frankly I can’t remember how I did it!! I do remember knitting a mitten for my sister for Christmas one year. Notice I said “a mitten”. In only had time to finish one before Christmas and somehow never got around to knitting the second one. I wonder if she still has it… 

Fast-forward to this year, and I decided it was time to tackle Fair Isle mittens again.

Choosing the Pattern and Yarn

I chose the Lumi Mittens by Ida-Maria Tyyskä because of the the snowflake design and traditional Fair Isle pattern.

I took my pattern to Colorful Yarns, a local yarn store in Centennial, Colorado, and asked for recommendations. They suggested Berroco Ultra Wool DK, and I chose two shades of pink, one dark and one light.

I love this yarn! It was easy to work with, and the finished mittens are super soft.

A Little More Challenging Than I Expected

Looking back, this pattern may have been a bit ambitious for my current knitting skills. I managed to finish both mittens (an improvement over my sister's Christmas gift!), but there was a lot of frogging (pulling out rows of knit stitches) along the way as I miscounted on the pattern.

Then there was the provisional cast-on for the thumb. I struggled with it on the first mitten. By the second mitten, I managed to get the cast-on right, but I struggled with removing it to knit the thumb. Next time a pattern calls for a provisional cast-on, I will practice.

Will I do it again?

Now that the mittens are finished, I can look back and say it was a positive experience. But I also remember being pretty unhappy at times while I was knitting them!

There were plenty of mistakes, a lot of unraveling, and more than a few moments of frustration. Still, I finished both mittens, learned a few things, and have a beautiful, soft pair to show for it.

Next
Next

Yarn Pirate: A Thrift Store Treasure